Cash settlement for dead miner's family
A Bath company has paid an undisclosed figure to the family of a man crushed to death six years ago when a mine collapsed.
The family of 37-year-old Steve Cosh have this week confirmed they have reached an out-of-court settlement with the Bath Stone Group, although the firm says it admits no liability for the incident, which it believes was an accident.
Mr Cosh, from Radstock, was working for the company at Stoke Hill Mine in Limpley Stoke in September 2006 when the roof of the mine collapsed and he was crushed by a one and a half ton lump of limestone.
The stepfather of three had been working alone beyond the furthest line of roof bolts used to secure the ceiling when the collapse happened.
Business Cards From Only £10.95 Delivered www.myprint-247.co.ukView details
Our heavyweight cards have FREE UV silk coating, FREE next day delivery & VAT included. Choose from 1000's of pre-designed templates or upload your own artwork. Orders dispatched within 24hrs.
Terms: Visit our site for more products: Business Cards, Compliment Slips, Letterheads, Leaflets, Postcards, Posters & much more. All items are free next day delivery. www.myprint-247.co.uk
Contact: 01858 468192
Valid until: Wednesday, May 22 2013
Despite the efforts of his work colleagues, who removed the boulder using a forklift truck, Mr Cosh was pronounced dead when he reached hospital.
In 2007 Avon Coroner's Court delivered a verdict of accidental death and said the circumstances of the incident had been unforeseeable.
But the Cosh family vowed to take the stone company to court and, speaking this week, Mr Cosh's widow Sarah said: "It is a huge relief that this matter has finally been resolved. The entire family can now attempt to move on from the horror of Steve's accident.
"He enjoyed his work and was a great family man. He is missed terribly by everyone who knew him. This money can never replace him but we feel that it is some recognition of the fact that we believe he died needlessly."
Law firm Thompsons, acting for the National Union of Mineworkers (NUM), which represented the Cosh family, claimed information presented to Mr Cosh's inquest had been flawed and that there had been health and safety breaches which caused or contributed to the roof's collapse.
Thompsons said it believed that failures by the stone company included the failure to ensure ground control measures were in place to keep the mine secure, and a failure to follow its own set of "managers support rules".
Lawyer Anthony Welsh said the case had been difficult.
"Our experts identified what they said were a number of breaches which caused or contributed to the roof collapsing. The defendants' own experts corroborated our evidence and in the end we believe the employers had no choice but to settle the claim."
NUM official Wayne Thomas added: "Roof falls are among the largest cause of injuries in the mining industry and strict Health and Safety Executive regulations are designed to prevent these from happening. It was clear to us that Steve's death was caused by his employer's failure to abide by these well-known regulations and we were determined to ensure that his family received justice."
But Elaine Marson, chairman of Bath Stone Group, said the company stood by the inquest's verdict.
She said: "After a protracted and jury-led inquest, the coroner's verdict on Steven's fatality was one of 'accidental and unforeseeable death' and this we still stand by.
"We are held up by our official body, the Mines Inspectorate, as an exemplar of good health and safety practice, and rigidly adhere to this regime at all times.
"Whilst we have every sympathy with Steven's family, and were all devastated by his death, we admit no liability whatsoever for this sad and unfortunate accident."